Translate But Don’t Editorialize
We just saw a case of an attempt to translate the pragmatics of a text instead of the text itself.
In general, a text will have a variety of implications, morals, allusions, etc. I think that a good translation of the text will match the original with a translation that has similar implications, morals, allusions, and so forth. Sometimes, however, translators are tempted to focus on one aspect of the text; then they translate that aspect instead of the text. The chart at the right depicts the two approaches.
For example, the “golden rule” is explained in Matthew 7:12 as outos gar estin o nomos kai oi profitai, “for this is the law and the prophets.” Ignoring for the moment what exactly “the law and the prophets” is (probably the Jewish Canon at the time), we still find translation variations for outos gar estin. For example (with my emphasis):
- this is…. (ESV, NAB)
- this sums up…. (NIV)
- this is a summary of…. (NLT)
- this is the meaning of…. (NCV)
- this is what [the Law and the Prophets] are all about…. (CEV)
- add up [God’s Law and Prophets] and this is what you get. (The Message)
I think that the NIV, NLT, NCV, CEV, and The Message get it wrong. Each of those versions translated something related to the text instead of the text itself.
Presumably, the translators for some of these versions decided that it’s just not true that the Law “is” the Golden Rule, but if so, what they missed is that it’s equally (un)true in Greek as it is in translation.
Perhaps the point of the passage is that the golden rule sums up the Law and the Prophets, but again, even if that’s true, “sums up” doesn’t seem like the right translation, because I don’t think it’s the job of the translation to jump from the text to its point for us.
By focusing on the point, or the moral, or the message, of the text, translators disguise their interpretation as translation. (This is, by the way, what I think Dr. Leland Ryken dislikes so much about the translations he criticizes, and I think in this regard he is correct to protest.)
It seems to me that when the lines between commentary and translation are blurred, it does a disservice to both.
December 18, 2009 Posted by Joel H. | Bible versions, translation practice, translation theory | Bible, Bible translation, CEV, ESV, golden rule, Matthew 7:12, NAB, NCV, NIV, NLT, the law and the prophets, The Message, translation | 13 Comments
About
God Didn’t Say That (@GodDidntSayThat) is an online forum for discussing the Bible and its translations, mistranslations, interpretations, and misinterpretations.
Dr. Joel M. Hoffman is the chief translator for the ten-volume series My People’s Prayer Book, author of And God Said: How Translations Conceal the Bible’s Original Meaning, and editor of The Unabridged Bible. Writing under “J.M. Hoffman,” he is author of the thriller series The Warwick Files. He holds a PhD in theoretical linguistics and has taught at Brandeis University and HUC-JIR in New York City. He presents widely to churches, synagogues, and other groups. more…
Have a question or a topic you’d like addressed? Click on “About” here or to the far upper right and leave a comment.
Of Note
Top Posts
Blogroll
Subscribe!
Search for:
Recent Comments
My Non-Fiction
- The Bible Doesn't Say That: 40 Biblical Mistranslations, Misconceptions, and Other Misunderstandings (St. Martin's Press, 2016)
- The Bible's Cutting Room Floor: The Holy Scriptures Missing From Your Bible (St. Martin's Press, 2014)
- And God Said: How Translations Conceal the Bible's Original Meaning (St. Martin's Press, 2010)
- In the Beginning: A Short History of the Hebrew Language (NYU Press, 2004)
My Fiction
My thriller series: The Warwick Files.
"A police chief with a secretive past. A quiet New York City suburb. And, officially, no spies."Watch the trailer: Archives
- April 2017 (1)
- March 2017 (2)
- April 2016 (1)
- March 2016 (2)
- February 2016 (2)
- October 2015 (1)
- September 2015 (4)
- June 2015 (1)
- February 2015 (2)
- December 2014 (1)
- October 2014 (3)
- September 2014 (1)
- July 2014 (1)
- March 2014 (1)
- January 2014 (2)
- November 2013 (3)
- October 2013 (1)
- September 2013 (3)
- July 2013 (1)
- May 2013 (1)
- March 2013 (2)
- February 2013 (1)
- January 2013 (2)
- December 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (4)
- October 2012 (3)
- September 2012 (1)
- August 2012 (2)
- July 2012 (2)
- June 2012 (3)
- May 2012 (7)
- March 2012 (1)
- February 2012 (3)
- January 2012 (6)
- December 2011 (1)
- November 2011 (4)
- October 2011 (5)
- September 2011 (3)
- July 2011 (1)
- June 2011 (4)
- May 2011 (4)
- April 2011 (7)
- March 2011 (6)
- February 2011 (3)
- January 2011 (6)
- December 2010 (2)
- November 2010 (9)
- October 2010 (7)
- September 2010 (3)
- August 2010 (3)
- July 2010 (8)
- June 2010 (6)
- May 2010 (6)
- April 2010 (9)
- March 2010 (15)
- February 2010 (19)
- January 2010 (21)
- December 2009 (21)
- November 2009 (23)
- October 2009 (39)
- September 2009 (45)
Categories
- announcements (24)
- article review (2)
- audio (2)
- Bible versions (56)
- biblical interpretation (7)
- blog review (1)
- book review (2)
- editorial (1)
- general linguistics (32)
- grammar (9)
- meta (15)
- Off Topic (26)
- other (1)
- Q&A (33)
- translation applications (3)
- translation challenge (18)
- translation practice (173)
- translation theory (184)
- Translation Traps (17)
- Uncategorized (6)
- using Bible translations (8)
- video (4)
Tags
alma And God Said anthropos Bible Bible interpretation Bible translation Bible versions Biblical prophecy Bill Mounce book giveaway CEB CEV dragon dynamic equivalence ESV formal equivalence gender gender accuracy Genesis Genesis 1:1 GNB God's Word grammar Greek Greek grammar Hebrew Hebrew grammar idiom imagery Isaiah Isaiah 7:14 Job Joel M. Hoffman John 3:16 JPS King James Version KJV Leviticus 18:22 linguistics LXX Matthew Matthew 1:18 metaphor Modern Hebrew NAB nephesh NIV niv2011 NJB NLT NRSV parthenos poetry proof text Psalm 23 Rashi reading level sarx semantics sin Song of Solomon Song of Songs son of god syntax Ten Commandments The Message TNIV to'evah translation translation theory Translation Traps travel virgin birth word order year in review